Trading in Tropes: Video Mashup Shows What TV Writers Think of “Berkeley”

By Krissy Eliot

As the 2015 enrollment data shows, the real UC Berkeley is an extremely diverse place. But UC Berkeley as depicted on television? Not so much.

TV Land has been slow to surrender its use of Berkeley as code for Birkenstock-wearing, bean-sprout-loving, radical feminist tree-huggers. Only a few shows are acknowledging the contemporary reality of an institution perennially ranked at or near the top of the public universities worldwide.

“There are a handful of schools in the United States that have a mythic identity, and Berkeley is one of those,” says Robert Thompson, the nation’s go-to professor for pop culture expertise and director of the Bleier Center for Television and Popular Culture at Syracuse University.

Script writers deploy that identity as a kind of shorthand. Carmela Soprano in The Sopranos fretted to a neighbor that although she is “hoping and praying to Jesus” that her daughter gets into Georgetown, “She keeps talking about Berkeley….Berkeley!” On Family Ties, ex-hippie parents Steven and Elyse Keaton fondly recalled their “Blowing in the Wind” years at Berkeley while struggling to raise kids they fear are too conservative and materialistic, not to mention enamored of Ronald Reagan. And in Gilmore Girls, Type AAA overachiever Paris Geller lampoons one of her teachers for his Berkeley degree, saying, “He may have majored in math, but what did he minor in? Bean sprouts? Forget it.”

And that’s just for starters. Check out what TV shows really think of Berkeley in this CALIFORNIA mashup:

Many Cal students agree that their university’s radical reputation is outdated. “The city of Berkeley is still ‘hippie-ish’ but the university itself isn’t—at all,” one student writes on the popular message board College Confidential. “It’s a pretty normal university, at least compared to the 60s and 70s.”

Increasingly, Berkeley is coming to signify something else entirely: a tough school to get into. Just listen to alum California Gov. Jerry Brown, who attended Berkeley in the 60s. “It just feels that whatever used to belong to the normal people of California—assuming the Brown extended family is normal—it’s not available anymore,” Brown said at a University of California Board of Regents meeting earlier this year. “And so you got your foreign students and you got your 4.0 folks, but just the kind of ordinary, normal students, you know, that got good grades but weren’t at the top of the heap there—they’re getting frozen out.”

Thompson suggests the entertainment world may eventually catch up to reality. “If you were to go up randomly to an overachieving 17-year-old who was getting ready to decide where they’re going to apply to college, and you said ‘Berkeley,’ I think that they would be much less likely to give you a series of descriptions that I grew up with for Berkeley—protest, hippies, all the rest of it,” he says. “They’d be more likely to say, ‘Oooh, I don’t know if I have the SAT scores to get into Berkeley.’ ”

Share this article:
Google+ Reddit

Comments

Class of 1958. Was and is the greatest public university if not the greatest public or private university on the planet. Even normal people like me were able to go. Price in relation to minimum wage was reasonable and I got the greatest education a human being on the planet could want. Hippie? Yuppie? Radical? Maybe but like books written on the ’50’s and ’60’s just a slice of what the university was and still is. When I tell people, especially young people that I graduated from Berkeley, there is a wide eyed Wow! and praise. Worked my kazazka off but well worth it. Helped me get part-time jobs, got to go to great plays, concerts and symphonies in S.F. by being an usher (for free), saw some great music events in the men’s gym, in the football stadium, and the Greek Theater. Every thing one would want in a great university education and I WAS THERE!!!
The quality on that video is terrible!
I was at Berkeley ’73-’75. By that time serious protests were over. I can remember some SDSers handing out questionnaires in my genetics class, trying to find out of the prof was racist (no). They were six radicals in search of a cause. I had some great profs, including John Holdren, now Pres Obama’s science advisor. I learned about global warming in the winter quarter, 1975, in Holdren’s Quantitative Aspects of Global Environmental Problems. Decades later, his class informed this article I wrote in Environmental Health Perspectives: http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3339477/
Honestly, I have problem with media writers who keep regurgitating same findings. It is common knowledge that UC Berkeley is an extremely diverse institution. What television says may be of little importance. Perhaps the media and external linkages office may be responsible for under performing! The brand image of the institution to a big percentage lies in this office!
To be honest, I like your content. The glossary looks pretty nice! You’re a great writer and I agree with you, of course! The California’s university’s radical reputation is outdated.

Add new comment