|
Praxis
Shame and blame
by Eleanor Black Watkin
Mental health stigma is the worst it's been in 50 years
You couldn't find a
worse poster child for the
mentally ill, but Cho Seung-Hui
is now the most famous in the
United Statesif not the world.
The 23-year-old Virginia Tech
student shot and killed 32 faculty
and peers on April 16, the
worst mass killing in U.S. history.
His action also struck a blow to
attempts to de-stigmatize mental
illness that will impede change "for
years to come," says Stephen Hinshaw,
chair of Berkeley's psychology
department and author of The
Mark of Shame: Stigma of Mental
Illness and an Agenda for Change.
"This is exactly the kind of
incident that is damaging, done by
a violent, paranoid individual with
access to weapons, who could
become the face of mental illness,"
says Hinshaw. But even discounting
Cho, the stigma surrounding mental
illness is worse now than 50 years
agodespite the self-help culture,
the popularity of psychotherapy,
and the availability and effectiveness
of drugsargues Hinshaw,
drawing on 30 years of research,
including his own work on attention
deficit hyperactivity disorder.
Media portrayal of the mentally
ill is a large part of the problem, he
says. You don't hear about mental
illness unless something goes
wrongmental hospitals are closed
and patients end up homeless on
the streets of Berkeley and San Francisco, for example. And journalists
still use inflammatory language
when discussing mental
illness. Coverage of the Virginia
Tech shootings, for example,
described Cho as "deranged," "a
nut," and "a lunatic." "This kind
of language is inherently distancing,"
says Hinshaw. It also lumps
all mentally ill people into one category
dangerous. In fact, fewer
than 10 percent of the mentally
ill are violent, says Hinshaw. "We
are more successful now at treating
mental illness than we are at treating
cancer or heart disease, but
you'd never know that, because the
stereotype is that the mentally ill
are irrational, it's permanent, they
are incurable."
Families suffer, too, through
association. Cho's parents, a
South Korean couple who run
a laundry business, and his older
sister, a college graduate now
working for the State Department,
have apologized for his
actions. Besides their griefthey
also lost their son and brother,
and have expressed shock that
he was capable of murderthey
may also feel responsible.
"Throughout much of the 20th
century, the predominant psychological
model was that parenting is
the primary cause of all forms of
behavior, especially mental illness,"
explains Hinshaw, whose own
family struggled to cope with his father's bipolar disorder. "We have
gone into a more medical/biological
view these days, given evidence
that serious mental disorders have
a strong genetic component. Yet
families may now be blamed not
only for their childrearing practices
but also for having passed on
'defective' genes."
Given this climate, it's not surprising
that those needing psychiatric
help are reluctant to seek it.
The 2005 National Comorbidity
Survey found that fewer than half
of Americans with mental illnesses
sought treatment that year, and
those who did waited an average
of ten years from diagnosis to
seeking help.
Clearly, this allows violent,
unwell people like Cho to slip
through the cracks, although talk
about profiling potential school
shooters is unlikely to produce
a solution, says Hinshaw. "The
problem with such profiling is
that whereas a fair number of mass
murderers may show certain signs
or characteristics, only a small
minority of people showing such
characteristics are likely to develop
into mass murderers. How many
false positives are we willing to
have, to ‘catch' the small subgroup
who later cause disproportionate
trouble?"
The world's oldest operating mental
hospital, London's Bethlem Royal Hospital
popularly known as "Bedlam," now a
synonym for uproar and confusion
opened in 1247. During the 18th century,
touring the asylum with its 200 chained,
screaming inmates was a popular weekend
pastime. It is estimated that Bedlam
attracted 19,000 visitors a year.
|