|
Show
The multiple Hawking universe
by Charlotte Stoudt
In his Oppenheimer Lecture and in conversations
with Berkeley Nobelist George Smoot,
the world's most famous physicist reveals cosmic genius
 Justin Sullivan/Getty Images News
The vast stage at Zellerbach Hall is
almost empty, save for a couple of perfunctory ferns and a microphone center
stage, lowered as if for a child's talent show. the sold-out crowd is buzzing,
excited. Stephen Hawking is about to give the annual Oppenheimer Lecture.
At the first sight of Hawking in his wheelchair,
the noise drops to a whisper. A sandyhaired
assistant rolls his chair to center stage
and bends next to him, speaking quietly into
his ear. Hawking's computer beeps, whirs. He
wears a brown jacket and trousers, an open-collared
shirt. Slightly twisted in his chair, motionless
except for an occasional involuntary lift of
his right knee, his posture has an odd aspect of
martyrdom. It's the palpable tension between
the wasted bodyalmost inanimate, a discarded
puppetand the intense, fixed gaze. Everyone
breathes quietly, watching Hawking. We may
all be in the same room, but the evident effort
and technology required to move his thoughts
into our brains recalibrates how we listen.
Time. Slows. Down.
One is reminded of the famous comparison
made by George Smoot, Berkeley cosmology
professor and 2006 Nobel Prize co-winner. He
likened searching for evidence of the Big Bang's
cosmic background radiation to "listening for a
whisper during a noisy beach party while radios
blare, waves crash, people yell, dogs bark, and
dune buggies roar."
Hawking, 65, has suffered for more than
four decades from amyotrophic lateral sclerosis
(ALS, also known as Lou Gehrig's disease), the
progressive degeneration of the central nervous
system cells that control voluntary movement.
His ability to speak and move has gradually
deteriorated, and in 1985, during a bout of
pneumonia, he had an emergency tracheostomy.
His vocal chords were removed so he
could keep breathing.
California engineer Walter Woltosz, whose
mother-in-law suffers from ALS, created the
software that allows Hawking to communicate.
When the physicist twitches his right cheek, the
muscle movement is read by an infrared beam.
The beam permits Hawking to move through a
menu of words onscreen in order to build sentences,
which are then sent to the voice synthesizer
and spoken by an American-accented male
voice. Hawking, who arguably has more to say
than most of us, can program 1520 words a
minute. Most English speakers average 150200 words per minute.
At Zellerbach, the assistant steps away.
Silence, heavy and full. And then Hawking's
famous computer-synthesized voice: "Can you
hear me?"
Like the Big Bang cosmology he's helped
to popularize, Hawking is at once a given and
utterly unknowable. Physicists now posit 11
dimensions and possibly unlimited universes.
But we certainly inhabit a world of multiple
Stephen Hawkings: Rock Star, Innovator, Disability
Champion, Working Physicist.
The Rock Star is onstage. This is the man
who makes instant headlines by announcing he
plans to go into space by 2009, whose musings
on the fate of humanity for Yahoo Answers generate more than 25,000 responses, and who is
surely the only Cambridge University Lucasian
professor of Mathematicsa post once held by
Sir Isaac Newtonto guest star on both Star
Trek and The Simpsons. His 1988 book, A Brief
History of Time, has purportedly sold one copy
for every 750 people on earth.
Hawking's Oppenheimer Lecture is a basic
primer of cosmology, an ongoing process by
which human beings learn to let go of what
we want the universeand our place in itto
be and instead accept what the data imply. For
centuries, Hawking points out, the Western
world believed in Aristotle's vision of a universe
that had existed forever. "Something eternal,"
observes Hawking's computerized voice, seemingly
with the faintest trace of irony, "is more
perfect than something created."
In 1929, Hawking tells us, Edwin Hubble's
discovery that space was in fact expanding
"transformed the debate about whether the
universe had a beginning." The logic was clear:
"If galaxies are moving apart now, they must
have been closer together in the past. If their
speed had been constant, they would all have
been on top of one another about 15 billion
years ago." Evidence for that hypothesis came
in 1965, when a faint background radiation of
microwaves was discovered throughout space.
"These microwaves are the same as those in
your microwave oven, but very much less powerful,"
explains Hawking. Then he can't resist:
"They would heat your pizza only to –271.3º
centigrade, not much good for defrosting the
pizza, let alone cooking it."
Variations in these microwave readings indicated
this radiation was left over from "a very hot
and dense state"the Big Bang. The readings
also suggest that the early universe was irregular
in density. And this, emphasizes Hawking,
is key: "Some regions will have slightly higher
density than others. The gravitational attraction
of the extra density will slow the expansion of
the region and can eventually cause the region
to collapse to form galaxies and stars."
Beep, pause. "So look well at the map of
the microwave sky. It is a blueprint for all the
structure in the universe. We are the product
of quantum fluctuations in the very early universe."
Another pause. (Hawking's synthesized
timing is spot on.) "God," he says, completing
his thought by contradicting Einstein, "really
does play dice."
There is something deeply theatrical about
this moment. The world-famous wheelchaired
physicist telling usby flipping Einstein's oftquoted
dictumjust how random our existence
really is. And we have to believe him. After all,
doesn't the genius diagnosed with a fatal condition
at the start of his brilliant Oxbridge career have an inarguably visceral knowledge of
chance? Who knows more about the effects of
gravity than a physicist who can't move?
Whatever anyone sayseven the man himselfit is almost impossible to separate the
content of Rock Star Hawking's discourse from
the conditions of his existence. Errol Morris,
who directed the evocative 1991 documentary
based on Brief History, calls Hawking "the first
non-talking talking head." For philosopher
Hélène Mialet, Hawking embodies "the mythical
figure of genius capable of grasping the ultimate
laws of the universe with nothing but the
strength of his reasoning." The tension between
Hawking's inability to control his body and his
seemingly superhuman mind appears to be a
Cartesian triumph: I think, therefore I amdespite my crippling disease. He is the ultimate
poster boy for our faith in the supremacy of
Occidental rationalism.
Other physicists, among the least easily
impressed people on the planet, marvel at
Hawking's ability to do calculations in his head.
"He must have an enormous power to process
problems without ever doing any writing," says
friend and fellow physicist Stanley Deser. "Even
Einstein used to sweat with a pencil and paper."
Backward in time: Tuesday afternoon,
the day before Hawking's Oppenheimer Lecture.
Now Hawking the Innovator sits at the front
of LeConte 1, a steeply raked lecture hall that
feels like a time capsule from the early 1960s.
Packed with physics students, the room is stifling.
Students in wheelchairs arrive and sit in
the front. George Smoot, buoyant and smiling,
steps forward to introduce Hawking. "Recently
I have found myself reviewing who and what
influenced my life and career…. Stephen was
one of those for me." (Hawking, in turn, calls
Smoot's and research partner John Mather's
1992 observations of the universe in its infant
stages "the greatest discovery of the century, if
not of all time.")
It was at Berkeley in the late 1930s, incidentally,
that some of the major initial thinking
on black holeswhich Hawking has done
so much to help us understandwas accomplished.
J. Robert Oppenheimer and his students
calculated the conditions under which a
star would collapse. But they did not address
what happens inside the star itself. Some 30
years later, this question would drive Hawking's
work on quantum gravity.
| Page 1 |
| |
2 |
 |
|
|