Close Mobile Menu

Terrible Lizards, Better Birds

September 16, 2009
by Erik Vance
photograph of a fossilized lizard

How birds are helping scientists understand dinosaurs

As you probably know by now, dinosaurs didn’t really go extinct—they evolved into birds.

The paradigm-shifting moment came in 1964 when Yale paleontologist John Ostrom found a dinosaur fossil that reminded him more of a modern raptor than it did a lizard. The discovery led Ostrom to conclude that birds, not reptiles, are the closest living relatives of dinosaurs.

“Birds are a kind of dinosaur. That hasn’t been in serous discussion for two decades,” says Kevin Padian, a former student of Ostrom’s who is now a Berkeley professor and curator of the paleontology museum. “We just can’t even conceive of what dinosaurs were like by looking at reptiles today.”

Padian is part of a new generation of paleontologists who take the dinosaur-bird link as a starting point. Rather than trying to find more evidence to buttress the connection, he says, “We kind of turn it around and say, if birds are a kind of dinosaur, where do they get their attributes from?” It is proving to be a fruitful line of inquiry.

Paleontologists had long wondered, for example, why so many dinosaur fossils are found in the classic death pose—head thrown back, spine arched. The general assumption had been that the contortions resulted from post-mortem desiccation. That conjecture had a problem, however: If the carcasses had been drying in the sun, why hadn’t they been devoured?

Birds provided a clue. Padian’s colleague, Cynthia Marshall Faux of the Museum of the Rockies, a veterinarian as well as a paleontologist, immediately recognized the posture as one she’d seen in asphyxiated birds. The insight led her and Padian to posit that the dinosaurs, possibly suffocating in gases and ash from volcanic eruptions, had assumed the pose during their death throes.

In another paper, published this year, Padian’s lab quantified the growth rates of some dinosaur species. Ornithologists know a mother bird’s bones grow an extra layer just before she lays her eggs. After a similar feature was discovered in Tyrannosaurus rex, Berkeley researchers, by counting layers of bone in fossil specimens, were able to determine that dinosaurs like the fearsome Allosaurus developed quickly, becoming sexually mature in adolescence.

The paleontology department, which pre-dates the University itself, was folded into Integrative Biology in 1989, around the same time that Ostrom’s ideas were becoming mainstream. While the move has had its disadvantages (space constraints, for example, mean that some of the University’s fossils must be stored in the Campanile), it has also had the advantage of placing under one roof scientists who study living birds and those who study their Jurassic relatives—a disciplinary proximity that promises to yield more discoveries regarding the “terrible lizards.”

Share this article

Related Articles

Lisa White heads the education program at the University of California's Museum of Paleontology. (photo by Laura B. Childs)

Bones to Pick: UC Berkeley Paleontologist Entices Diverse Students to Dig Her Field

Lisa White scrunches her nose and holds a magnifying glass up to one eye to inspect a peanut-sized vial seemingly full of large tan and ivory sand grains. But a closer look reveals rods, stars and corkscrews—the 50-million-year-old fossilized shells of forams, creatures that still populate the oceans today. “You’re gonna see some cool stuff […]

New Global Warming Remedy: Turning Rangelands into Carbon-Sucking Vacuums

Studies conducted on a ranch in the heart of Marin County and led by UC Berkeley researchers and alums seem to confirm what home gardeners have long suspected: Compost really can save the world. That sounds hyperbolic, of course. But research led by Whendee Silver of Berkeley’s Department of Environmental Science, Policy, and Management concludes […]

Toward a Common Wealth

If you’ve been paying attention to the economic news you’ve probably noticed pundits using an ecological metaphor: Green shoots are sprouting. It’s a nice image. First the blackened earth of economic collapse, then tender leaves of recovery pushing up from below. If they said instead that we were seeing the early signs of infection, that wouldn’t work so well. Economic growth is never portrayed as the vine that strangles, the multiplication of locusts—it’s always the heroic sprout. The metaphor must jibe with an assumption so fundamental that few stop to consider it: Growth is good.