Slippery Slopes and Other Concerns About End of Life Options

A Q&A on the ethics of aid-in-dying with Dr. Guy Micco
By Leah Worthington

As of 2016, the California End of Life Option Act offers legal protection to residents suffering from terminal illness who wish to access medical aid-in-dying, also known as physician-assisted suicide. But the law has hardly quelled the controversy. We spoke with Dr. Guy Micco, co-director of the Program for Medical Humanities at Berkeley who has had a long-standing interest in aging and death, about the ethical concerns in legalizing life-ending treatment.

What are the main arguments against allowing aid-in-dying?

Those who believe that we are only caretakers of our own lives, that this life is a gift from God, see it as morally wrong to hasten the end; for God is the only ‘One’ who can properly decide when we die.

Some disability activists find medical aid-in-dying (MAID) an affront to the dignity of those with severe disabilities whose lives might be seen by others as “not worth living.” Such an attitude leads to a discounting of the life of someone with a disability; further, it can be internalized by that person.

Some secular bioethicists, physicians, and others believe that physicians should never be in a position to take life. They point to the fact that good palliative care and hospice are very successful at controlling severe pain, shortness of breath, and other physical symptoms at end-of-life. Further, they may point out that there is a “slippery slope” in play: First, assisted death for the terminally ill, competent person. Then, assisted death for the non-terminally ill, competent person. Then, we move to assisted death for the person who cannot truly give their consent because of, say, dementia or coma. Finally, we become so inured to killing that we have involuntary euthanasia (killing against the will of the person), as seen in Nazi concentration camps.

How do you respond to the fear of a slippery slope?

The slippery slope argument was recently made anew in an editorial in the journal JAMA Internal Medicine (2020) by geriatrician and palliative care physician Diane Meier.

She points out the problem of imperfect safeguards, or the impossibility of safeguards, surrounding the extension of euthanasia beyond terminal illness for a consenting adult; further, she says that this is already happening in the Netherlands. Letters from Dutch physicians, in response to her editorial, claim this is not the case. But having watched the use of MAID in our community, I tend to agree: Safeguards, such as assuring a patient’s consent and desire for MAID, are in place. Abuses can be prevented. However, I do have a lingering concern as articulated by the disability community.

Which concerns do you think are most valid and why?

I am quite sympathetic to the view of disability activists: First give us the right to a decent life, then talk to us about a “right to die.”

Fear of severe disability and age-related illness is near-universal, including among physicians. This may result in “the unconscious projection of support for a hastened death” (Meier)—a version of, “Of course you want to die, no one would want to live like you’re living. Let us help you.” If the life of a person with a severe disability is thought not worth living, how easy might it be to push that person toward MAID? The same might be said regarding elders toward the end of their lives: “You’ve lived a good life. Why are you hanging on?”

More and better education for us all regarding disability, old age, and the meaning of “quality of life,” along with appropriate safeguards for MAID, go a long way toward alleviating my concerns. But in the end, the question is one for society to answer: Should the value of autonomous decision-making take precedence over safeguarding the lives of the most vulnerable? And, if so, what safeguards must be in place to prevent abuses?

From the Summer 2021 issue of California.
Image source: AP Photo / Rich Pedroncelli
Share this article:
Google+ Reddit


I understand and appreciate the key points that have been put forwards, and disability, old age and hopelessness have been mentioned. But then, there are also situations in everybody’s life when a spouse or child have reached a medical situation where basically no hope for “getting back to normal” is left…just continuing unbearable physical pain and suffering with no end in sight. For the surviving spouse there is the daily begging from the afflicted “to do something”, hemlock society and all. It may take weeks and even months which may break the heart of the survivor. And yet…life continues, the good memories remain and forever lingering love for the deceased.
Do You Need A Powerful Africa Native Doctor? I Mean A Spiritual Herbalist With Great Spirit Connected To Ancestors. Call or WhatsApp +2349058774809 Dr Obodubu Monday Is A High Voodoo Priest Master. He is a Spell Caster, Native Doctor, Spiritual Herbalist, Powerful Sickle cell Healer, Spiritual Astrologer, Psychic Reader, Multi Guru, Witch Doctor, Priest Of Africa Money Ritual. Have You Been To Native Doctor to Native Doctor Without Any Solution To Your Problems Or Rather Add To it? Have You Been To Place To Place In View Of A Powerful Native Doctor That Can Solve All Your Predicament, You Must Understand That There Is A Native Doctor That Supersede All Native Doctor Among All Native Doctor, If You Are In Search Of A Powerful Native Doctor With Great Spiritual Powers, Then You Must Be In Search Of A Native Doctor That Derives Power From The Marine World. That Is The Spirituality Of The Greatest Africa Native Doctor Obodubu. Dr Obodubu Is Recognized All Over The World Of Marine Kingdom, As One Of The Top Fortunate And Most Powerful Native Doctor Of Charms Casts From The Beginning Of His Ancestors ship Until Now Dr who lives Strong Among All Other Native Doctors, There Have Never Been Any Form Of Impossibility Beyond The Control Of Dr Obodubu. It Doesn’t Matter The Distance Of The Person With The Problems Or Situation, All You Have To Do Is Believe In The Native Obodubu charms Casts That Works, He Always Warns Never To Get His Charms Casts If You Do Not Believe Or Unable To Follow His Instruction. It Is The Assignment Of The Native Doctor Obodubu To Offer Services To Those In Need Of Spiritual Assistance Not Minding The Gravity Of Your Situations Or Distance As Long As Water, Sea, Ocean, Lake, River Sand etc. Are Near You, Then Your Problems Of Life Would Be Controlled Under Your Foot. If You Need Any Spiritual Help On Any of These: Get Your Lover Back Fruit Of The Womb Fibroid Business Boom Financial Breakthrough Get Rich Without Ritual WhatsApp +2349058774809 Do As I Say Bad Dream Promise And Fail Epilepsy Spiritual Attack Land/Court Case Mental Disorder Political Appointment Visa Approval Cancer Examination Success Spend And Get Back Good Luck Natural Health Hypertension Diabesity (Diabetic+Obesity Stroke Sickle Cell Impotency Win Court Case Promotion At Work Commanding Tone Protection Ring Marriage Success Love Ring Favour Ring Recover Lost Glory Spiritual Power For Men Of God Travel Success Ring Job Success Lotto/Pool Win And Many More. Make Haste To Call or WhatsApp Dr Obodubu Monday +2349058774809. Or Mail Him to For Spiritual Problem Today And You Will Surely Get Solution To All Your Predicament. Email:
How I Got My Husband back… Am so excited to share my testimony of a real spell caster who brought my husband back to me. My husband and I have been married for about 6 years now. We were happily married with two kids, a boy and a girl. 3 months ago, I started to notice some strange behavior from him and a few weeks later I found out that my husband is seeing someone else. He started coming home late from work, he hardly cared about me or the kids anymore, Sometimes he goes out and doesn’t even come back home for about 2-3 days. I did all I could to rectify this problem but all to no avail. I became very worried and needed help. As I was browsing through the Internet one day, I came across a website that suggested that Dr. obodubu monday can help solve marital problems, restore broken relationships and so on. So, I felt I should give him a try. I contacted him and told him my problems and he told me what to do and I did it and he did a spell for me. 48 hours later, my husband came to me and apologized for the wrongs he did and promised never to do it again. Ever since then, everything has returned back to normal. My family is living together happily again.. All thanks to Dr. obodubu monday If you have any problem contact him and I guarantee you that he will help you. He will not disappoint you. you can WhatsApp him +2349058774809 or Email him at :
Here comes an Easy way to become a member of the world’s famous brotherhood {Illuminati}. For the working class, Business men/ women, artists, Politicians that want to become bigger, Powerful and Influential in the world, join us to become one of our official members today. You shall be given an ideal chance to visit the Illuminati circle after registration is completed by you, no sacrifice or human life needed, Illuminati brotherhood brings along protection, power, wealth and fame in life. You have full access to eradicate poverty from your generation. It is only an existing member of the circle of Illuminati that has the authority to introduce any member to the circle. So before you contact us, you must be above 18yrs and once you become a member you will be entitled to all the benefits for the rest of your life. if you are ready to become a member, contact me on whatsapp +1 (646) 328-7046 email: illuminati1stseniortemple for further details.