Vaccine Passports: Are They Legal—Or Even a Good Idea?

By Glen Martin

Even as California inches toward economic and social reopening, the virus is running rampant in other states—most notably, Michigan—and outside the U.S., in countries that have received little or no vaccine. There is increasing concern that the highly contagious variants now circulating could fuel a nationwide surge this summer.

Thus, the interest in so-called COVID “passports”: app-accessed digital certifications that confirm inoculations against the coronavirus. They would allow vaccinated people to gather en masse at concerts and sporting events, in gyms, and on cruises and flights, secure in their mutual immunity.

Berkeley Law Professor Dorit Rubinstein Reiss says vaccine passports
are indeed
legal. “The controversy is strictly a political one.”

But the concept hit roadblocks almost immediately, with vaccine opponents and many conservatives declaring certification an invasion of privacy. Some business coalitions also backed away from them, fearing consumer backlash. The Biden administration has declared it will not enforce a verification mandate nor maintain a federal vaccination database. And the governors of Texas and Florida have announced bans on vaccine passports, barring businesses and government agencies from requiring them.

Indeed, many civil libertarians have questioned the essential legality of vaccine passports. But there’s no significant ambiguity on that point, says Berkeley Law Professor Dorit Rubinstein Reiss, an authority on vaccine law and policy.

“They’re legal,” says Reiss. “The controversy is strictly a political one. That said, the language is sloppy. There’s no single ‘passport.’ There are a range of tactical issues that bear on vaccination certification.”

U.S. Supreme Court rulings have upheld compulsory vaccination laws. In a 1905 case, Jacobson v. Massachusetts, the Court declared states were authorized to require and enforce mandatory vaccinations. And in Zucht v. King in 1922, the Court determined that the San Antonio, Texas, school district had a constitutional right to bar unvaccinated students from its campuses.

Currently, employers and public institutions can require vaccinations subject to certain limits detailed in the 1964 Civil Rights Act and the Americans with Disabilities Act of 1990, says Reiss.

Legalities aside, there’s the question of public health. Are vaccine passports a credible mechanism for keeping people safe?

“Under the Civil Rights Act, employers must provide a ‘reasonable accommodation’ to an employee who expresses a sincere religious belief that would prevent them from getting vaccinated,” Reiss says. “But the employer could still require vaccinations for such employees if it imposes an ‘undue hardship’ on the company’s operations.”

Similarly, disabled employees can be exempted from compulsory vaccination if their disabilities raise safety concerns, says Reiss.

“Employers have to participate in a ‘good faith’ process to determine if the disability is a qualification for an exemption and if the employee can be protected from COVID while working,” she says. “An op-out can hinge on the availability and effectiveness of PPE [personal protective equipment] such as masks and face shields. And again, the employer can still require vaccinations if it imposes ‘undue hardship’ on the company.”

Likewise, universities and other public institutions can require mandatory vaccinations, subject to the same stipulations of the Civil Rights Act and the ADA, Reiss says.

Still, some uncertainty over the issue remains due to the process used by the U.S. Food and Drug Administration to green light COVID vaccines. The FDA sanctioned the vaccines under an Emergency Use Authorization (EUA)—essentially, an acknowledgement that the vaccines were fast-tracked and not subjected to the standard regulatory process; technically, they are not federally approved, nor are they licensed.

“Under the EUA, the Secretary of Health and Human Services allowed the use of the vaccines, but taking them remains a matter of personal choice,” says Reiss. “It’s unclear where it all goes because nothing has been interpreted by the courts yet.”

“There are so many barriers to getting vaccinated now that passports aren’t really fair.” —John
Swartzberg

Unions may also figure into vaccination requirements, she says. “The collective bargaining agreement of a unionized workforce may limit the ability of an employer to require vaccinations without engaging in negotiations with the union.”

But when it comes to travel requirements, Reiss says “there’s not much that can be done to resist that legally.” Foreign countries have sovereign authority to require vaccination documentation, and airlines and cruise lines are generally allowed to impose restrictions as well.

Legalities aside, there’s the question of public health. Are vaccine passports a credible mechanism for keeping people safe?

John Swartzberg, a clinical professor emeritus of infectious diseases and vaccinology at Berkeley’s School of Public Health, thinks so—with a couple of caveats. First, like Reiss, he doesn’t feel “vaccine passport” is the best possible name for vaccine certifications.

“Also, before I’d endorse the idea, I’d want to make sure that everyone who wants a vaccination can get it,” says Swartzberg. “And by that I don’t mean vaccines simply become theoretically available to everyone, as was the case when California authorized vaccinations for everyone 16 and older on April 15. I mean everyone who wants one can easily obtain one within a fifteen-minute drive. There are so many barriers to getting vaccinated now that passports aren’t really fair.”

No matter how COVID passports play out legally, says Reiss, the associated politicization is unlikely to diminish.

By summer the situation should be more equitable, says Swartzberg, “and then a lot of good could come from these certifications. If you knew everyone in the airport, on your airline, at a baseball game or your favorite restaurant was vaccinated, you’d feel a lot more secure about going places and doing the things you enjoy. I’m in my 70s now, and I want to teach next semester. I’ll feel a lot better about going on campus if I know that everyone—students, faculty, and staff—are vaccinated.”

Swartzberg emphasizes that vaccine certifications are nothing new.

“I grew up with the ‘yellow card,’ the yellow fever vaccination certificate that was widely required for international travel,” Swartzberg says. “We need thoughtful discussion on COVID matters, including vaccine passports—but everything is politicized, particularly in states such as Texas and Florida.”

And no matter how COVID passports play out legally, the associated politicization is unlikely to diminish, says Reiss.

“For certain people, they’re a rallying cry,” she says. “The implementation is likely to be piecemeal. As I said, they’re generally legal—but I expect them to remain controversial.”

Share this article:
Google+ Reddit

Comments

Do You Need A Powerful Africa Native Doctor? I Mean A Spiritual Herbalist With Great Spirit Connected To Ancestors. Call or WhatsApp +2349058774809 Dr Obodubu Monday Is A High Voodoo Priest Master. He is a Spell Caster, Native Doctor, Spiritual Herbalist, Powerful Sickle cell Healer, Spiritual Astrologer, Psychic Reader, Multi Guru, Witch Doctor, Priest Of Africa Money Ritual. Have You Been To Native Doctor to Native Doctor Without Any Solution To Your Problems Or Rather Add To it? Have You Been To Place To Place In View Of A Powerful Native Doctor That Can Solve All Your Predicament, You Must Understand That There Is A Native Doctor That Supersede All Native Doctor Among All Native Doctor, If You Are In Search Of A Powerful Native Doctor With Great Spiritual Powers, Then You Must Be In Search Of A Native Doctor That Derives Power From The Marine World. That Is The Spirituality Of The Greatest Africa Native Doctor Obodubu. Dr Obodubu Is Recognized All Over The World Of Marine Kingdom, As One Of The Top Fortunate And Most Powerful Native Doctor Of Charms Casts From The Beginning Of His Ancestors ship Until Now Dr who lives Strong Among All Other Native Doctors, There Have Never Been Any Form Of Impossibility Beyond The Control Of Dr Obodubu. It Doesn’t Matter The Distance Of The Person With The Problems Or Situation, All You Have To Do Is Believe In The Native Obodubu charms Casts That Works, He Always Warns Never To Get His Charms Casts If You Do Not Believe Or Unable To Follow His Instruction. It Is The Assignment Of The Native Doctor Obodubu To Offer Services To Those In Need Of Spiritual Assistance Not Minding The Gravity Of Your Situations Or Distance As Long As Water, Sea, Ocean, Lake, River Sand etc. Are Near You, Then Your Problems Of Life Would Be Controlled Under Your Foot. If You Need Any Spiritual Help On Any of These: Get Your Lover Back Fruit Of The Womb Fibroid Business Boom Financial Breakthrough Get Rich Without Ritual WhatsApp +2349058774809 Do As I Say Bad Dream Promise And Fail Epilepsy Spiritual Attack Land/Court Case Mental Disorder Political Appointment Visa Approval Cancer Examination Success Spend And Get Back Good Luck Natural Health Hypertension Diabesity (Diabetic+Obesity Stroke Sickle Cell Impotency Win Court Case Promotion At Work Commanding Tone Protection Ring Marriage Success Love Ring Favour Ring Recover Lost Glory Spiritual Power For Men Of God Travel Success Ring Job Success Lotto/Pool Win And Many More. Make Haste To Call or WhatsApp Dr Obodubu Monday +2349058774809. Or Mail Him to babadoctorobodubuspiritualhome@gmail.com For Spiritual Problem Today And You Will Surely Get Solution To All Your Predicament. Email: babadoctorobodubuspiritualhome@gmail.com
How I Got My Husband back… Am so excited to share my testimony of a real spell caster who brought my husband back to me. My husband and I have been married for about 6 years now. We were happily married with two kids, a boy and a girl. 3 months ago, I started to notice some strange behavior from him and a few weeks later I found out that my husband is seeing someone else. He started coming home late from work, he hardly cared about me or the kids anymore, Sometimes he goes out and doesn’t even come back home for about 2-3 days. I did all I could to rectify this problem but all to no avail. I became very worried and needed help. As I was browsing through the Internet one day, I came across a website that suggested that Dr. obodubu monday can help solve marital problems, restore broken relationships and so on. So, I felt I should give him a try. I contacted him and told him my problems and he told me what to do and I did it and he did a spell for me. 48 hours later, my husband came to me and apologized for the wrongs he did and promised never to do it again. Ever since then, everything has returned back to normal. My family is living together happily again.. All thanks to Dr. obodubu monday If you have any problem contact him and I guarantee you that he will help you. He will not disappoint you. you can WhatsApp him +2349058774809 or Email him at : :babadoctorobodubuspiritualhome@gmail.com
Here comes an Easy way to become a member of the world’s famous brotherhood {Illuminati}. For the working class, Business men/ women, artists, Politicians that want to become bigger, Powerful and Influential in the world, join us to become one of our official members today. You shall be given an ideal chance to visit the Illuminati circle after registration is completed by you, no sacrifice or human life needed, Illuminati brotherhood brings along protection, power, wealth and fame in life. You have full access to eradicate poverty from your generation. It is only an existing member of the circle of Illuminati that has the authority to introduce any member to the circle. So before you contact us, you must be above 18yrs and once you become a member you will be entitled to all the benefits for the rest of your life. if you are ready to become a member, contact me on whatsapp +1 (646) 328-7046 email: illuminati1stseniortemple @gmail.com for further details.
People make life difficult for their self , we are in the world were everything is in control , i was living a life of poverty and pains, i never new there was a life be young that, but right now i enjoyed every dividend of life , am rich , famous , powerful,i live a life with out no stress, The brotherhood bought me a house and a car. for any body who want riches famous and power,house and a car then you have the chance to do that, join the illuminati today to get whatever you want in life and become rich and also get the same of $1 million [USD] in Nigeria naira is .381,000,000.00 Nigerian Naira for members how are ready to join this great Illuminati brotherhood blessing. Whats-app +2349028225257 Us now OR call +2349028225257 OR message us on gmail. Justincott40@gmail.com We don’t patronize people to join. If you are interested you contact us.Say bye bye to poverty by joining Illuminati i never believe not until i finally join but now i am rich..this man Mr Justin cott is real he made me what i am today and i am very proud of me begin a Illuminati member… if they, can make me rich make me become something in life why don’t you join also for you to also be rich the money always flows through the members like an ocean that never runs dry contact him for help to join :::: NOTE; that in the Great Brotherhood of Illuminati no Bloodshed and no Humans sacrifices is involved [we don’t kill for anything] OK… Do not miss this opportunity THANKS..
People make life difficult for their self , we are in the world were everything is in control , i was living a life of poverty and pains, i never new there was a life be young that, but right now i enjoyed every dividend of life , am rich , famous , powerful,i live a life with out no stress, The brotherhood bought me a house and a car. for any body who want riches famous and power,house and a car then you have the chance to do that, join the illuminati today to get whatever you want in life and become rich and also get the same of $1 million [USD] in Nigeria naira is .381,000,000.00 Nigerian Naira for members how are ready to join this great Illuminati brotherhood blessing. Whats-app +2349028225257 Us now OR call +2349028225257 OR message us on gmail. Justincott40@gmail.com We don’t patronize people to join. If you are interested you contact us.Say bye bye to poverty by joining Illuminati i never believe not until i finally join but now i am rich..this man Mr Justin cott is real he made me what i am today and i am very proud of me begin a Illuminati member… if they, can make me rich make me become something in life why don’t you join also for you to also be rich the money always flows through the members like an ocean that never runs dry contact him for help to join :::: NOTE; that in the Great Brotherhood of Illuminati no Bloodshed and no Humans sacrifices is involved [we don’t kill for anything] OK… Do not miss this opportunity THANKS..
Hello viewer am Kombe from Kenya 29 years old am here to share my testimony on how i joined the brotherhood of illuminati.. four months back when i wanted to join the brotherhood i was scammed by fake agents and people pretending to be Grand Master use the website.. until i met a friend MR BERRY CASTLE who gave me the genuine procedures i followed and made me a member of the great brotherhood of illuminati. today i am living a good life and i have enough money to do all i ever wanted .if u are interested and u need the help of my Initiator Berry. Call or Whats’App MR Berry Castle +1(779) 324-0633 thanks Berry, am living the dream i will forever be grateful.
Hello viewer am Kombe from Kenya 29 years old am here to share my testimony on how i joined the brotherhood of illuminati.. four months back when i wanted to join the brotherhood i was scammed by fake agents and people pretending to be Grand Master use the website.. until i met a friend MR BERRY CASTLE who gave me the genuine procedures i followed and made me a member of the great brotherhood of illuminati. today i am living a good life and i have enough money to do all i ever wanted .if u are interested and u need the help of my Initiator Berry. Call or Whats’App MR Berry Castle +1(779) 324-0633 thanks Berry, am living the dream i will forever be grateful.
Only dogs must wear face masks and receive inocculations without their concent. Stop apartheid!
Hello everyone i want to testify  on how I joined the illuminati  kingdom  and my life change totally . i become rich and famous.  I was trying to join this society for so many years  I was scammed before I was down i could not feed my self and my family anymore and I tried to make money by all means but all in vain, I was afraid to contact any illuminati agent because i was scam before . finally a friend of mine introduce me to the right way to join illuminati. I was initiated, surprisingly I was given an instant benefit money of $2,000,000.00 as a new member of the great illuminati kingdom  I was very happy, for those of you trying to join this illuminati society  this is your opportunity for you to join.  Contact the illuminati official  email: illuminatiworldrich02@gmail.com or  WHATSAPP call/text  + 1 (917) 336 2320  on how to join, i want you all to know that it is totally free on how to join the illuminati, this is the real illuminati temple where you can join and be totally free in life and be successful.